Resin Injection vs Traditional Concrete Underpinning: Which Is Better for Structural Repairs?

In this article, we explore resin injection vs. concrete underpinning (the traditional form of foundation support), helping you choose the right solution for your property.

Resin Injection vs Traditional Concrete Underpinning: Which Is Better for Structural Repairs?

If your home is showing signs of foundation movement, cracking or settlement, you may come across two very different repair options: resin injection and traditional concrete underpinning.

Both methods can have a place in foundation repair, but they work in fundamentally different ways.

At Fred R. Heimann Co. Pty. Ltd., we specialise in traditional concrete underpinning. For structural foundation problems, we believe the first priority should be understanding why the building has moved and choosing a repair method suited to that particular problem.

What Is Resin Injection?

Resin injection involves pumping an expanding resin into the ground beneath a footing, slab or other affected area.
As the resin expands, it can fill voids, compact surrounding soil and, in some circumstances, provide enough pressure to lift a sunken section.

One of its main attractions is that it can often be carried out quickly and with relatively little excavation.
In the right application, resin injection can be useful. However, whether it is appropriate depends on the structure, soil conditions and cause of the movement.

What Is Traditional Concrete Underpinning?

Traditional concrete underpinning takes a different approach.

Sections are excavated beneath the existing footing and new concrete underpinning sections are constructed below it. The purpose is to extend the existing footing down to suitable founding material capable of supporting the building.

Where appropriate, the affected section of the structure may also be carefully lifted during the underpinning process.
Traditional concrete underpinning has been used for decades as a method of providing additional structural support to existing foundations.

Resin Injection vs Concrete Underpinning: What Is the Difference?

The major difference is how the building is supported.

Resin injection introduces material into the ground beneath or around the existing foundation.

Traditional underpinning physically extends the footing deeper into the ground.

For homeowners comparing the two, the most important question should not simply be which method is quicker or less disruptive.

The better question is:

What is causing the building to move? And which repair method is appropriate for that cause?

When Resin Injection Can Be Useful

Resin injection can have a legitimate role in foundation and ground remediation.

Depending on the circumstances, applications may include:

  • lifting uneven concrete paths
  • correcting some driveway settlement
  • filling voids beneath concrete
  • supporting certain non-structural slabs
  • situations where professional assessment determines injection is appropriate

Its relatively low level of excavation can make it attractive for suitable applications.

However, these situations can be quite different from providing structural support beneath the foundations of a house.

Why We Prefer Traditional Concrete Underpinning for Structural Repairs

At Fred R. Heimann Co. Pty. Ltd., we specialise exclusively in traditional concrete underpinning.

For genuine structural foundation movement, traditional underpinning provides a clear method of transferring the load of the building to deeper, suitable founding material.

The process involves:

  • structural engineering
  • soil testing
  • calculated underpinning depths
  • building permits 
  • inspections during construction
  • documented structural repairs

We hold a DB-U Unlimited building registration, allowing us to undertake structural building work of this type.

That documentation can also be important when a property is eventually sold, particularly if a building inspection identifies evidence of previous movement or cracking.

Can Resin Injection Fail?

Like any foundation repair method, resin injection is not suitable for every situation.

We have attended properties where resin injection had previously been carried out and cracking or movement later returned. In some of those cases, traditional concrete underpinning was subsequently required.

That does not mean every resin injection job will fail.

It does demonstrate why identifying the cause of the movement before choosing a repair method is so important.

Long-term results can be influenced by factors including:

  • soil type
  • changing soil moisture
  • drainage
  • leaking pipes or drains
  • tree roots
  • footing depth
  • the depth of the affected soil
  • whether the original cause of movement remains active

Reactive Clay Soils and Foundation Movement

Many Melbourne, Geelong and Victorian homes are built on reactive clay soils.

These soils can expand as moisture levels increase and shrink as they dry. Over time, these changes can contribute to movement beneath foundations.

Trees, leaking drains, poor site drainage and extended dry periods can also influence soil moisture and foundation movement.

Where significant structural movement has occurred, simply lifting an affected area does not necessarily mean the underlying cause has been resolved.

This is why proper investigation is important before undertaking major foundation repairs.

Why Engineering Matters

Cracking does not automatically mean a house needs underpinning.

There are many possible causes of building movement, including:

  • seasonal soil movement
  • changes in soil moisture
  • poor drainage
  • leaking plumbing or stormwater
  • large trees
  • historic settlement
  • inadequate footing depth
  • nearby excavation

A structural engineer can help determine what is causing the movement and whether underpinning, resin injection or another approach is appropriate.

Is Resin Injection Cheaper Than Traditional Underpinning?

The cost of both methods varies considerably between properties.

Resin injection can involve less excavation and may therefore appear to be the simpler option in some situations.

Traditional underpinning generally involves considerably more physical work and also involves engineering, permits and inspections.

However, the important consideration is not simply the initial cost. The repair method needs to be appropriate for the particular foundation problem affecting the property.

How Much Does Traditional Underpinning Cost?

Underpinning costs vary depending on factors such as:

  • the number of underpinning sections required
  • excavation depth
  • access
  • soil conditions
  • engineering requirements
  • the amount of lifting required
  • site conditions

For a more detailed explanation, see our guide:

Foundation Repairs in Melbourne & Geelong: Costs, Timeframes & What to Expect

Resin Injection or Concrete Underpinning: Which Should You Choose?

There is no single repair method suitable for every property.

Resin injection can be useful in the right circumstances.

Traditional concrete underpinning is generally considered where the existing footing itself requires additional structural support and needs to transfer the building load to deeper, suitable founding material.

Before choosing either method, it is worth establishing:

  1. What is causing the movement?
  2. Is the movement still occurring?
  3. What are the soil conditions?
  4. How are the existing footings performing?
  5. What repair method is appropriate for the structure?

Once those questions have been answered, choosing the appropriate repair method becomes much easier.

Traditional Concrete Underpinning in Melbourne and Geelong

Fred R. Heimann Co. Pty. Ltd. has been carrying out underpinning work in Melbourne and Geelong since 1983.

We specialise in traditional concrete underpinning and do not provide resin injection systems.

If your property has cracking, settlement or signs of foundation movement, we can discuss the problem with you and help determine whether traditional underpinning may be appropriate.

Need Advice About Foundation Movement?

If you’re comparing resin injection and traditional concrete underpinning, feel free to Contact Us.

Send us some details about the property through our Contact Form. Photographs of the cracking and any engineering information you already have can be emailed to us once initial contact has been established.